Saturday 21 January 2012

Tesco profit warning - how much was Clubcard responsible?

If they say a picture is worth a thousand words then the following graph is no exception.

TescoReward

Using Tesco market share data from TNS/Kantar Worldpanel, there seems to be an interesting correlation between changes in their market share and changes in the reward value of Tesco Clubcard.

With declining market share in 2007-2008, Tesco implemented the Double Points Promotion which gave customers a huge lift in loyalty value and in response, Tesco didn't just stem the decline in market share, they lifted it 5.5% from 2008 levels.

In 2010 the double points promotion was changed to make it less generous, reducing reward deals from 4x value to 3x. This still meant the reward value was higher than the original scheme, but it was much less than customers had been getting used to during 2009.

Despite this positive impact on market share however, Tesco decided to change strategy, moving from a loyalty focused approach to a price focused one. This took a huge amount of value out of the Clubcard programme and pushed it into £500m of price discounts.

At the time a Tesco spokesperson was reported to have said:-

"Our customers have said what really matters to them at the moment, is the price at the till"

This is no surprise - customers will always say that it's price that matters, whether it's boom or bust. What is a surprise is that Tesco listened to this feedback and then acted on it. With ASDA already having a price match promotion and Sainsburys quickly implementing their coupon at till Brand Match promotion, Tesco's big gesture around price was essentially neutralised. This also didn't go unnoticed by ASDA, who at the time said:-

"Yawn. We were 10 per cent better value yesterday. We're 10 per cent better value today. We'll be 10 per cent better value, whatever they do, come Monday."

In the process though Clubcard had taken a double whammy. Not only had they reduced the value of the scheme to it's lowest point ever, but by reducing prices in-store they had taken further value away of around 1.2%.

For an average loyal Tesco Clubcard customer who was shopping in-store, picking up Tesco fuel and using their credit card for purchases, this change amounted to a 40% drop in value from the high of 2009.

What did they get for this? Well just over 346,000 extra customers according to Kantar.

How many of these will stick around though is the more interesting question. As The Daily Telegraph said in it's article "The cuts that lost Tesco £5bn of its value"

"Though Tesco shoppers took advantage of the lower prices, they did not feel they were getting a bargain and failed to return for another shop"

It seems Tesco forgot how powerful loyalty could be and played straight into the hands of EDLP retailers like ASDA. Whilst publicly they are now focusing on their store offering as the new point of difference, it will be interesting to see if Clubcard once again takes centre stage.

Example Tesco Clubcard Reward Value

Category

Monthly

Spend

2008

Original

B/E(4x/1x)

2009

2x Points

B/E(4x/2x)

2010

3x Deals

B/E(3x/2x)

2011

Current

B/E(3.2x/1x)

2011

Current (Adj)

B/E(3.2x/1x)

Supermarket£600£24.00£48.00£36.00£22.40£22.12
Fuel£240£9.60£9.60£7.20£8.96£8.96
Car Insurance£25£1.00£1.00£0.75£-£-
Credit Card£1,000£10.00£10.00£7.50£7.47£7.47
Monthly Reward
£44.60£68.60£51.45£41.6041.29
Annual Reward£535.20£823.20£617.40£499.16£495.50
Difference-£39.70-£327.70-£121.90-£3.66

Notes:

  1. Supermarket / Fuel spend calculated as spend via Tesco credit card
  2. Current Burn rate average as 3x across wide range of deals
  3. Current (Adj) assumes 1.27% lower supermarket spend due to £500m discounts across £39.3bn food sales (2010)
  4. Car insurance no longer has any active Clubcard deals

39 comments:

Mark said...

Interesting analysis! Thanks for putting it up. I am always amazed by loyalty cards. When I used to shop at Tesco the clubcard points were basically 1% refund of everything I spent. It would be much easier to just reduce prices by 1% (or more) and save a whole load of administration costs, but apparently people just lover their clubcards ! I will be watching Tesco's share price closely as they have to to be buy around these prices (IMHO).

Unknown said...

chanel handbags, http://www.chanelhandbags-outlet.us.com/
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors outlet
hollister canada, http://www.hollistercanada.com
ray ban uk, http://www.raybansunglass.co.uk
puma sneakers
nhl jerseys
koby bryant shoes
true religion jeans, http://www.truereligionjeansoutlets.us.com/
nike roshe run
links of london uk
cartier love bracelet
oakley sunglasses, http://www.oakleysunglassesdiscount.us.com
ugg outlet, http://www.uggsoutlet.us.org
beats headphones
nike huarache
rolex watches,rolex watches,swiss watches,watches for men,watches for women,omega watches,replica watches,rolex watches for sale,rolex replica,rolex watch,cartier watches,rolex submariner,fake rolex,rolex replica watches,replica rolex
michael kors canada, http://www.michaelkorsoutletcanada.in.net
tods shoes
oakley,occhiali oakley,oakley italia,oakley occhiali,oakley sunglasses
evening dresses
coach outlet
louis vuitton handbags
michael kors outlet store, http://www.michaelkorsoutletonlinstore.us.com
karen millen dresses, http://www.karenmillendressesoutlets.co.uk/
oakland raiders jerseys
tiffany and co
tods outlet
oakley sunglasses outlet
michael kors uk
2015910caihuali

柯云 said...

2016-05-30keyun
jordan retro 11
michael kors outlet
coach factory outlet
true religion jeans
nike running shoes for men
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet
coach factory outlet
air jordan femme
michael kors purses
coach outlet online
gucci handbags
toms
oakley sunglasses
the north face jackets
polo ralph lauren
christian louboutin shoes
michael kors outlet online
ray ban sunglasses uk
adidas factory outlet
kate spade handbags
tiffany & co
ray bans
adidas originals
michael kors outlet
ray ban sunglasses outlet
louis vuitton outlet
coach factory outlet online
cheap toms shoes
michael kors outlet
air jordan shoes
cheap ray ban sunglasses
michael kors outlet
coach outlet
ralph lauren outlet
louis vuitton bags
burberry sale
toms outlet
louis vuitton outlet stores

Unknown said...

coach outlet online
giuseppe zanotti shoes
true religion jeans
ray-ban sunglasses
ferragamo shoes sale
michael kors outlet
lululemon outlet
ugg uk,ugg outlet,ugg boots outlet
tiffany outlet
rolex watches
coach outlet
ferragamo shoes
oakley sunglasses wholesale
lebron shoes
polo ralph lauren
louis vuitton outlet
fitflops sale clearance
toms shoes
swarovski crystal
tory burch outlet
michael kors outlet
fitflops clearance
ferragamo shoes
ray ban sunglasses
michael kors outlet online
beats headphones
michael kors outlet
kobe 9 elite
michael kors outlet store
longchamp handbags
michael kors uk
michael kors canada
cheap uggs
longchamp outlet
0727JIANXIANG

chenlili said...

nike trainers
fitflops sandals
canada goose canada
ugg on sale
polo ralph lauren outlet
ralph lauren outlet
ray ban sunglasses
cheap ugg boots
michael kors outlet
adidas shoes
201711.2chenjinyan

chenmeinv0 said...

nike air max plus
ray ban
beats by dre
balenciaga shoes
air jordan
replica watches
montblanc
miu miu shoes
air max
air max 97
2018.4.26xukaimin

PPSSPP said...

PPSSPPmaster Gold apk for pc get free from here

SSSSSS said...

adidas gazelle
yeezy wave runner 700
lebron 15
foamposites
adidas superstar
jordan retro
nike lebron 11
longchamp handbags
lacoste online shop
adidas yeezy

56 said...

0806jejeLe jeu Air soldes basket asics femme Max Quarter et Air Max Pure sont également asics gel noosa tri 9 w femme des baskets de basket-ball Nike qui asics gel nimbus 18 Chaussures offrent les fonctionnalités de grande qualité nike air max 90 jacquard femme pour lesquelles Nike est célèbre. Une nike air jordan 1 retro high og carmine personne que je n'étais jamais prêt asics gel lyte iii kakishibu tan tan à faire était de prendre des suppléments avis sur chaussures asics illégaux ou tout type d'hormone de croissance. nike roshe run noir cdiscount

56 said...

0806jejeDans le cas 2015 nike air max huarache noir où vous avez l'intention d'habiller un favori, vous pourriez rapidement chaussure de skate nike sb étudier ces derniers sont tous partis depuis longtemps et air jordan pas cher boutique vous serez loin de la chance. Dernièrement, dans l'industrie asics gel lyte v homme noir du vêtement, il existe des possibilités illimitées Air Jordan 3 Baskets de choisir. À mon avis, ce sont certains des asics decathlon france meilleurs briquets à cigares là-bas pour votre argent durement adidas zx flux rouge et bleu gagné.

Image Editing Services said...

The information you have posted is very useful. The sites you have referred was good. Thanks for sharing.. Check out
photoshop cs6 shadow effect
real photo background changer
Neck Joint

PalaPala said...

Adidas Yeezy
Jordan 4
Kyrie Irving Shoes
Pandora Jewelry Official Site
Air Jordan 9
Pandora Jewelry
Pandora Outlet
Nike Air Max 270
Air Jordan 11
Latrice20181223

PalaPala said...

Jordan 11 For Sale
Air Jordan 4
Air Jordan 11
Nike Air Max 270
Pandora Jewelry
Kyrie 3 Shoes
Pandora Charms Outlet
Nike 270
Red Bottom Shoes
Latrice20181226

El Awal said...

شركة تنظيف خزانات ببريدة
شركة تنظيف ببريدة
شركة جلى بلاط ببريده
شركة تنظيف بالبكيرية
شركة تنظيف بالدوادمي
شركة تنظيف مساجد بالدوادمي
شركة تنظيف خزانات بالخرج
شركة تنظيف بالخرج
شركة تنظيف منازل بالخرج
شركة تنظيف مجالس بالخرج

http://ariadnetravel.com said...

Hello there I am so glad I found your blog page, I really found you by mistake, while I was looking on Bing for something else, Anyways I am here now and would just like to say thanks a lot for a marvelous post and a all round entertaining blog (I also love the theme/design), I don't have time to browse it all at the moment but I have book-marked it and also included your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read more, Please do keep up the awesome job. http://ariadnetravel.com/

https://casaparadiso.net said...

Nice post. I find out some thing very complicated on diverse blogs everyday. Most commonly it is stimulating to see content from other writers and employ a little something at their store. I’d choose to use some while using the content in my small blog no matter whether you don’t mind. Naturally I’ll supply you with a link on your web blog. Many thanks for sharing.    https://casaparadiso.net

Joker388 said...

Joker123
.
Joker388
.
Joker Gaming
.
Club388
.
Joker388
.
Joker123
.
Club388
.
Fafaslot
.
Fafa Slot
.
Fafaslot

bila ingin bermain mencoba saja keseruan yang ada di website resmi yang kami punya ini dengan nikmat

Mehndi Hai Rachne Wali said...

From MX Player original hindi shows to Hindi dubbed shows you can make your
weekend full of entertainment with these top 10 hindi web series streaming

Bobby Mughal said...

Zindagi Mere Ghar Aana (Star Plus) Cast and Crew, Roles, Release Date, Trailer.
Zindagi Mere Ghar Aana is a Star-Plus tv show. This tv show was produced by.

Anupama

Gaia1956 said...

advisor fiduciary

Gaia1956 said...

cleaning contractors

Gaia1956 said...

kiley juergens

Gaia1956 said...

degree courses

Imlie said...

Gautam and Dhara Pandya, a middle-class married couple, manage the Pandya Store.
Apart from their business, Dhara also looks after Gautam's three younger siblings.

Anonymous said...

Pinoy Channele bringing you best videos from all over Filipino entertainment, pinoy tv dramas show on https://teleseryee.su.

Anonymous said...

Pinoy Teleserye Replay has quite a few drama television listing airing in philippines. We replace the contemporary episodes of Pinoy Channel Tv daily.

https://teleseryee.su

KissAsian said...

KissAsian is the best website to Korean dramas and movies online free with
English Subtitles and Dubbed. This website Chris Gayle, movies of genres ...

Kepala Bergetar Watch Online said...

Just the website I was looking for. It's really awesome. I'll follow your footsteps
and if you want to watch Malay dramas online free episods daily then visit the link below.

Kepala Bergetar Watch Online

Drama Melayu Watch Online

Cut Out Image said...

I was exactly searching for this type of post. Thanks for such a great post and please keep it up. Nice work.

Thanks
Shadow Creation Service

Bigg Boss 16 Watch Online said...

Just the website I was looking for. It's really awesome. I'll follow your footsteps
and if you want to watch Indian dramas online free episodes daily then visit the link below.

Bigg Boss 16 Watch Online

Shadow creation service said...

Shadow creation service
Creating a drop shadow is a cycle that ought to go with your section as it assists with making your picture look more reasonable. This little realistic detail can truly have an effect since it makes the item more straightforward to examine.
Reflection Shadow
Photoshop Shadow Effect Service
Natural drop Shadow Service

Dramacool said...

DramaCool is korean tv kshow123 website which provides latest
Korean drama, movies, Kshow and kissasian dramas with english
subtitles online free in hd quality. DramaCool for everyone!


Dramacool

Tasha said...

They forgot loyalty

Lockdown 2 said...

Lockdown 2

Nice Post! I appreciate your Post, valuable photoshot. This list is really helpful. Thanks for posting.

Unknown said...

c7n27r0a79 y1y22z1z81 x5m84q7f89 p9s55j7n23 q8i40k2o02 w9u10a7a60

Wade Mathew said...

This is amazing information written by the author excellent work.

Economical altro safety flooring

Meghla said...

Really amazing article. It’s really helpful. Thanks for sharing.

Makki Oil said...

Fuel Efficiency: Some synthetic oils are designed to improve fuel efficiency. If this is a concern for you, consider oils formulated for better gas mileage.

engine oil

Max said...

"I just wanted to express my appreciation for this blog. It's like a virtual haven of positivity and wonder. I find myself eagerly anticipating each new post. Keep up the great work!"

app development dubai